Why Are You Like This?!
Michael Zook | October 21, 2026 | Beam, Powered by Arc
Every music teacher knows this moment. You give what you believe to be exceptionally clear instructions: “Measure 37. Pencil out. Altos only. Watch me.” A hand goes up. “What measure?” Your eye twitches. You breathe deeply…Le sigh
In these moments I’m reminded of a lyric from the musical Hamilton:
“Look at where you are. Look at where we started. The fact that you’re alive is a miracle!”
However, before you activate “Teacher Rebuttal Mode” and dismantle this student’s existence in front of all their peers…because let’s be honest, you have been refining this skill since before the flip phone…perhaps we should practice a behavior skill of our own: Empathy 🙂 Ask yourself, what if this student isn’t trying to give you a hard time? What if they are just lacking the skills to manage all the stimulus?
Dr. J. Stuart Ablon, Ph.D. is a clinical psychologist best known for his work on challenging behavior in children and adolescents and for developing and promoting the Collaborative Problem Solving approach. He is the founder and director of Think:Kids, a program in the Department of Psychiatry at Massachusetts General Hospital, and is an Associate Professor in Child and Adolescent Psychiatry at Harvard Medical School.
There are 5 Thinking/Behavioral Skills as outlined by Dr. J. Stuart Ablon:
- Language & Communication Skills — Understanding what others communicate and being able to express your own thoughts, feelings, concerns, and needs.
- Attention & Working Memory Skills — Maintaining focus, ignoring distractions, keeping information in mind, managing multiple pieces of information, and completing tasks in sequence.
- Emotion & Self-Regulation Skills — Managing strong emotions and impulses, pausing before acting, waiting, and adjusting your level of energy or arousal.
- Cognitive Flexibility Skills — Adapting to changes, transitions, uncertainty, different perspectives, and situations that don’t go according to plan.
- Social Thinking Skills — Reading social cues, understanding how your behavior affects others, taking another person’s perspective, and navigating interactions effectively. Think:Kids
Challenging behavior is often a problem of skill rather than will—especially skills involving flexibility, frustration tolerance, and problem-solving.
Here are five short stories, from the wild: five behavioral skills, five very familiar music-room moments, and five opportunities to replace “What is WRONG with you?” with the considerably more useful “What skill does this student need to learn?” Nobody is the villain. Nobody is a “bad kid.” Everyone just has developing brains, developing skills, and approximately 2 rehearsals left before the concert!
Story 1: “Wait…What Are We Doing?”
Attention & Working Memory Skills: Holding onto information long enough to actually do something with it.
TEACHER: “Grab a pencil, turn to measure 46, circle the dynamic, then start with
the altos at the pickup to beat four.”
STUDENT (Three seconds later): “Where are we?”
Before assuming they weren’t listening, consider what we just asked their brain to hold onto: pencil, measure 46, dynamic, altos, pickup, beat four—and probably stop thinking about lunch. Sometimes the information went in just fine. It just didn’t all stay there.
Try this: Give fewer directions at once, a few seconds pause between tasks, then before starting check for understanding.
Story 2: “BUT WE ALWAYS DO WARM-UPS FIRST!”
Cognitive Flexibility Skills: Adjusting when expectations, routines, or plans suddenly change.
TEACHER: “We’re skipping warm-ups today and going straight to the closer.”
Most students turn to the closer, but one student looks as though you’ve just announced the cancellation of music itself.
STUDENT: “But we ALWAYS do warm-ups first!”
What sounds like arguing may actually be a brain struggling to change tracks. Some students need a little more runway between what I thought was happening and what is happening now.
Try this: Preview changes when possible and give the student’s brain a moment to catch up with the new plan. Take a few minutes to calmly explain why the change is necessary, then check for understanding.
Story 3: The Great Folder Slam of 10:17 A.M.
Emotion & Self-Regulation Skills: Managing frustration, impulses, emotions, and energy when things get difficult.
A student misses the entrance.
TEACHER: “Again.”
Someone nearby giggles.
STUDENT: SLAMS their folder shut, with enough force to alter local weather patterns.
The folder isn’t really the issue. The student’s nervous system simply became louder than their ability to regulate it. If someone punches you, you have a big reaction…and this can be what it feels like for students with hyper-sensitive nervous systems. Pair that with conflict trauma, and their reaction is completely understandable.
Try this: Lower the emotional temperature before addressing the behavior. Regulation usually needs to happen before problem-solving can. AND IF YOU HEAR ANYTHING, HEAR THIS…where there is SHAME, growth cannot happen!! Not only do educators have to normalize the explanation of big emotions, but we need to teach the other students in the room that it is ok. Not an excuse, just an explanation…and with understanding, then growth can occur.
Story 4: “I DON’T KNOW!”
Language & Communication Skills: Putting into words, the thoughts, feelings, and concerns, of ourselves and others.
TEACHER: “Why didn’t you sing?”
STUDENT: “I don’t know.”
TEACHER: “Were you confused?”
STUDENT: “I DON’T KNOW.”
TEACHER: “What don’t you understand?”
STUDENT: “I. DON’T. KNOW.”
And sometimes…they really don’t!
Identifying what is wrong, organizing it into language, and explaining it to an adult while 47 classmates stare at you requires more skill than we sometimes realize. This is a skill that many adults never really master!
Try giving options instead of demanding an explanation. Work with the student to understand what they are experiencing, then come up with a solution together.
Remember, it is never the job of the student to tell you what they are going through. We shouldn’t assume they have those skills. It is always the job of the adult to help them figure out what is going on. AND YES…teaching is hard! 🙂
Story 5: “HE’S LOOKING AT ME.”
Social Thinking Skills: Social cues, understanding perspectives, and recognizing how our behavior affects others.
STUDENT: “Can you please tell him to stop?”
TEACHER: “Stop what?”
STUDENT: “Looking at me.”
You look across the ensemble. Another student is, in fact, existing approximately twelve feet away.
Social cues that seem obvious to us aren’t obvious to everyone. Facial expressions, sarcasm, personal space, tone, teasing, and knowing when a joke has officially stopped being funny are all skills.
Try this: Don’t assume the student “should know better.” Sometimes the social expectation needs to be explicitly taught. BUT REMEMBER, normalize the behavior so that it doesn’t cause shame, and be patient when explaining how the behavior is actually a deficit in skills.
One Last Thing…
BEAM gives students opportunities to practice many of these behavioral skills right alongside their musical ones. By intentionally building skills like impulse control, working memory, flexibility, communication, and emotional regulation into the rehearsal process, we can help students develop the tools they need to navigate both the music room and the world beyond it. After all, we’re not just teaching students how to make music—we’re teaching humans how to make music together.
The goal isn’t to excuse every behavior, but rather to understand what may be underneath it. When we identify the skill a student is struggling to use, suddenly we have something we can actually teach.
And before we judge too harshly which students need more flexibility, impulse control, working memory, communication skills, and emotional regulation, there’s one more thing to remember: Teachers also need to develop these skills 🙂